by stephiebaby » November 3rd, 2009, 4:13 am
"CAn someone please deifine "Magic"?"
Yes, magic was the belief in supernatural phenomena reinforced through trickery and simple medicine. Today the belief magic exists, but the trickery magic is now called illusions, magicians are illusionists. The herbalism is now botany, medicine and pharmacology. We now acknowledge there is no real magic and replace deception with showmanship and knowledge.
The belief of magic is merely another superstition/religion, or delusion.
"Magic is a state of mind. I want a thing . I send out a request into the universe. I light a few candles. Burn a little incense. I might get that which i requested but it all depends on my intent."
Your intent has nothing to do with it, and you have merely replaced god with magic. When you get what you wanted you praise magic (your prayers were answered), but when you don't get what you want you blame yourself (I'm not worthy of god's favours). Very christian, catholic even. Your intent and your rituals have no influence on the outcome.
"I dont think magic such as disappearing people out of boxes and levitating women works."
That's the only magic which does work, and it is now called illusions since magic is not real.
"There is also the power of the spirit, which has the ability to affect Cause and effect."
Yeah, so does my lucky coin. Or if I believed in such things I would convince myself it was true, but I'd never be able to prove it to anyone else. The spirit only influences things if you mean your personality. If you mean supernatural kind of spirit, then you are into delusions/religions.
"This is my kind of topic!
How is "magic" defined? When go study to become a mage, the first thing that they tell you "
It's better getting the diagnosis from the psychiatrist, not the patient. Just like religion you wont get truth from those within the fantasy.
"The Art of magic ties directly into religion. Go up to any Pagan and ask what the Christian equivalent of a spell is and they will say "a prayer." "
Don't forget the jesus magic, walking on water, healing the sick, rising from the dead.
"YOU BOTH ARE FIGMENTS OF MY IMAGINATION!! GOD HAS PUT YOU HERE TO TEST HOW LONG I CAN GET PISSED OFF BEFORE COMMITING SUICIDE!!"
Actually all existence is a figment of my imagination I created to amuse myself ;).
"BUT a self is me, the thinking part. It is clearly different from my body as I have personally experienced being outside my body."
Yeah, you've "experienced" being outside your body, others "experienced" being abducted by aliens, others "experienced" talking to dead people. The thinking part of you, is your brain, which is part of your body. Removal of the brain to experience being outside your body is not recommended.
"but far be it from me to call you a liar. I don't believe it to be possible, that's because I haven't experienced it for myself yet."
You can certainly call them highly doubtful, the person acknowledges this themselves. They are smart enough to realise they can't prove what they believe. And your doubt is not just because you have not experienced it, it is also because there is no proof or anything to suggest it is possible. Your doubt is rational, you do not need to excuse it.
"But what else is the bit that leaves the body "
The only bits that leave the body are dead cells, hair, faeces, urine, parasites, sweat, sound, heat etc.
"then what was it that had the first experience?
By your definition there was no self at that point, so how could it experience?
There has to be something there to experience the first experiences"
Unless the first experience makes the something. Or the basic template is what is there for the first experience, then it is individually shaped from that first experiences through every experience.
"Magick is the art and science "
Science is what you get when you remove the magic superstition from basic botany and pharmacology. Magic is anti science, and pseudoscience.
"It is the only part of us that is truly immortal."
And here we are back at religion. The desire for immortality, stemming from the fear of death.
"of course an outside observer who has no such certitude in the efficacy of magick will point to such as proof that magick is nonsense. The chaos mage who summons mickey mouse as a vassal will of course disagree"
But like angels, your cartoon vassel cannot effect the real world. It cannot interact with me in any way, for example.
nuit09,
I think Indiana Jones said it best, "What a vivid imagination".
"And they can definitely kick your ass if they want to unless you are a real magickal bad ass."
This is like curses. They only work on believers. A non chemical voodoo curse will have no effect on a non believer, but can have a placebo effect on a believer. Ever wonder why tribal magic had no effect on firearms?
"The western mages suggest it for a couple of reasons. firstly folks who tended to come to them for training tended to have serious personality defects and imbalances"
It is one reason for people seeking out belief systems. It is also what cults use to great advantage.