by Lord_Mizaru » July 7th, 2005, 9:57 pm
Well. Where should I start.... you have so many things to correct. I have played the high end Roland's, and they don't sound half as good (in my opinion granted) as the Yamaha's. And yes, I mean the piano, as well as a lot of other sounds. The MOTIF8 is the most amazing synth I've ever played. That being said, no keyboard, be it acoustic or digital has had ivory keys in god knows how long (digitals ever actually) because that is ridiculously expensive now that you can't just go and shoot an elephant. And what the key feels like really has very little to do with how it sounds or even plays, so that entire comment you made is redundant.
How can you even suggest that midi sounds better than the real thing? I'll grant you that one day it might be possible, but to date I have yet to hear a single midi sound which I would take over the acoustic equivalent. If you're playing pop, even some kinds of jazz, I'll grant you that a synth is infinitely better than an acoustic if that's the sound you're after, but to play classical on it is impossible; at least if you intend to perform it the way it is meant to be. Why you ask? Well I'll grant you that it may sound similar if you get an ultra high end synth, but let's take the case of a piano since it's one near and dear to my heart. Now sure you can have pressure sensitive keys that will give you all the dynamics, but I assure you there's more than one sound you can have at the same dynamic level. Depending on how you strike the key, how long you hold it, even how you feel the damn thing is going to affect the sound that is produced, often greatly. A synth does not (to date) mimic that at all. There is no difference between a sound that is produced by going into the key or out of the key (if you understand what I'm talking about, most people who play will).
Let's talk about the pedal while we're at it. Sure you can buy an attachment pedal. But it doesn't work like the real thing. I have yet to hear one that can have different levels to it, one that can make strings sound when pressed quickly. I have yet to play on a single synth that feels like a piano either. Sure they have weighted keys, hell the MOTIF8 even has the exact same action they use in their grands, but it doesn't feel like a piano at all. Why? No after touch, no escapement action, no hammer ever hits the strings; the list goes on and on. And yes, all of these things matter. They matter immensely.
But wait, I'm not done yet. I went to your blog. You're to be commended for your ventures into esoterics. But I'm afraid that you have a fair amount of your techniques wrong. Opening the third eye in the manor you've suggested can be quite dangerous. I'm also worried that you don't suggest any meditations to go with it. Your description of where to place the tongue is in fact wrong; to complete the microcosmic orbit circuit, you actually have to place the tongue in a different location. And also your technique for belly breathing is incorrect; it should ideally be 7 seconds in and out. Note that I didn't tell you where the correct placement of the tongue is; that's because it's a closely guarded secret known only to students of the Tao. You'll forgive me for not posting it publicly since I was asked not to share knowledge such as that before I myself was taught.
Now after all this ranting, know that I have no ill feelings towards you. At least you spell out what you mean and genuinely seem to mean it. Your techniques of esoterics, while wrong by what little I've been taught, may very well work for you. But they are incorrect in terms of how they are intended to be done, and be done most effectively.